Litigation support · Guide

Law firm conflict check procedure

A conflict check procedure is a defined search of the firm's client and adverse-party records, run before engagement and documented with a timestamp. The search has to include related entities and close name variants, not just the name on the intake form.

Muhammad DanishIndependent consultant · Updated 15 November 2026
On this page
  1. When to run a conflict check
  2. What to search
  3. Name matching that actually works
  4. The decision
  5. The record
  6. Re-running the check
  7. Screens and waivers
  8. Conflict checks and confidentiality
  9. A procedure for a small firm

A conflict check is a search, a decision and a record. Most firms do the search, improvise the decision, and skip the record — which is why conflict questions tend to surface later as a surprise rather than at intake.

For a small firm, the procedure does not need to be elaborate. It needs to be run every time, on the right names, and written down.

When to run a conflict check

Run it:

  • Before accepting a new matter — before the engagement letter is signed and before substantive information is received.
  • Before adding a party to an existing matter.
  • When a new adverse party appears — a new defendant, a third-party respondent, a subpoena recipient with an adverse interest.
  • When a lateral lawyer or staff member joins — their prior matters enter the firm's conflict universe.
  • When the firm is asked to act against an existing or former client in an unrelated matter.

The first one is the one firms remember. The others are where conflicts slip through, because they happen mid-matter when everyone is already busy.

The search is not limited to the name on the intake form. Search:

  • The client's full legal name and any trading names
  • Every adverse party named or likely to be named
  • Related entities — parents, subsidiaries, affiliates, joint ventures
  • Principals and officers where the entity is small enough that the individuals matter
  • Known aliases and prior names — including maiden names and former company names
  • The matter description — a search on "the Smith property dispute" can surface a related matter that a name search misses

For a corporate client, the entity that signs the engagement letter may be a subsidiary of a company the firm already acts against. The conflict is created by the corporate family, not by the signature block.

Name matching that actually works

A literal search fails on the variations that occur in real files:

  • `Smith` vs `Smyth` vs `Smit`
  • `Jon` vs `Jonathan`
  • `ABC Holdings, Inc.` vs `ABC Holdings LLC` vs `ABC Group`
  • Names with punctuation, suffixes, or a middle initial

Two practical rules:

  1. Search partial strings, not whole names. Search `smith`, not `John Smith`.
  2. Look at the results, not just the hit count. A fuzzy match needs a human decision; the tool cannot tell you whether it is the same person.

If the firm uses a spreadsheet, add a column for known aliases and search across it. If the firm uses a conflict tool, check how it handles corporate suffixes and common name variants.

The decision

A conflict check produces one of four outcomes:

  • No conflict — proceed.
  • Potential conflict, waivable — disclose to the affected clients and obtain informed consent where the rules allow.
  • Conflict that requires screening — the matter may proceed with an ethical screen in some circumstances, depending on the rules and the jurisdiction.
  • Non-waivable conflict — decline.

The legal framework in most states is built on the ABA Model Rules: Rule 1.7 for current-client conflicts, Rule 1.9 for former clients, and Rule 1.10 for imputation across lawyers in a firm. The details vary by jurisdiction, and some conflicts cannot be cured by consent.

The important operational point: the decision belongs to a lawyer, not to the person who ran the search. The search produces candidates; the lawyer decides.

The record

Document, for every check:

  • Date and time
  • Who ran it
  • The search terms used
  • The databases or lists searched
  • The results, including close matches that were cleared
  • The decision and who made it
  • Any disclosure and consent obtained

A check without a record is hard to prove later. The record does not need to be elaborate — a note in the matter file with the fields above is enough — but it does need to exist before the engagement begins.

The most common conflict-check failure is not a missed name. It is a check that was run and never documented, so nobody can show it happened.

Re-running the check

A conflict check is a point-in-time search. The conflict universe changes when the firm takes on new clients, when a party is added, and when a lawyer joins.

Re-run the check:

  • At every new matter
  • At every new party
  • At every lateral hire
  • When the firm is acquired or merges

Screens and waivers

Where the rules permit a screen, it needs to be real:

  • The conflicted lawyer is excluded from the matter
  • Access to the file is restricted, not just discouraged
  • The screen is documented and communicated to the affected client where required
  • The firm monitors compliance

A waiver needs to be informed. A one-line consent email that does not explain the conflict is weak evidence of informed consent. Explain the conflict, the risk and the alternatives, and keep the client's response.

Conflict checks and confidentiality

The conflict check itself must not disclose confidential information. Searching for a name is not a disclosure; telling one client about another client's matter is. Keep the check record separate from the matter file where the search terms would reveal confidential information about another client.

This is one of the reasons a conflict tool should log the search without exposing the underlying client data more broadly than necessary.

A procedure for a small firm

  1. One intake form that captures the client, adverse parties, related entities and matter description.
  2. One search list — a maintained database or spreadsheet of clients, former clients and adverse parties.
  3. One searcher — the person who runs the check, with a backup.
  4. One decision-maker — the lawyer who decides on close matches.
  5. One record — a standard note in the matter file.
  6. One re-run trigger — new matter, new party, new hire.

That is the whole procedure. It fits on a page and it can be run in minutes, which is the only way it will be run consistently.

Frequently asked questions

When should a conflict check be run?

Before accepting a new matter, before adding a party to an existing matter, and when a new adverse party appears mid-case. Run it at intake, not after the engagement letter is signed.

What names should be searched?

The client, every adverse party, related entities, principals and known aliases. Search both full names and common variants; a corporate family can create a conflict through a subsidiary whose name never appears on the intake form.

How should a conflict check be documented?

Record the date and time, who ran it, the search terms used, the databases searched, the results, and the decision. A check that is not documented is difficult to prove later.

What is the difference between a conflict check and a conflicts waiver?

The check identifies the issue. A waiver is the client's informed consent to proceed despite it. Some conflicts cannot be waived, so the check must reach a lawyer before the firm relies on consent.

Can a spreadsheet handle conflict checks?

For a very small firm, a maintained list can work, but only if it is searched consistently and the search is recorded. The failure mode is a name that was added to the list after the check, or a variant that was never matched.

LawFirmTools provides software tools only. Nothing here is legal advice, and LawFirmTools is not a lawyer or a law firm. This article is general information for legal professionals; it is not a substitute for professional judgment or for your state bar's rules.